Upper West Side Pizza — Pizza Pete's NY on Columbus Avenue

The Upper West Side pizza search, pinned to one shop

People who type Upper West Side pizza are usually looking for a neighborhood counter they can walk to or order from — not a citywide ranking and not a Midtown chain. Pizza Pete's NY is that shop: 528 Columbus Avenue, between 85th and 86th Street, ZIP 10024.

This page is the neighborhood pin for that query. We have been the Columbus Avenue pizzeria since 2003. There is no second Pete's on Broadway, Amsterdam, or Central Park West — those streets walk or deliver to this kitchen.

How to find 528 Columbus from the rest of the UWS

From Amsterdam Avenue in the 80s, walk one block east on 85th or 86th. From Central Park West in the 80s, walk one avenue west to Columbus, then to the 85th–86th block. From the American Museum of Natural History at 79th and Central Park West, head north into the mid-80s; the counter is between 85th and 86th, not on the museum steps.

The 86th Street trains put you a short walk from the same door. Pizza on 85th Street and pizza on 86th Street are this storefront — 528 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024.

What shows up on the board when you get here

The NY-style board is foldable cheese, pepperoni, Margherita, white, Sicilian, fresh mozzarella, grandma, buffalo chicken, veggie, and build-your-own. Specialty slices add chicken parm. Chicago Cheese and Chicago Fresh Mozzarella sit in their own pan-style category if you want a thicker pie without leaving the neighborhood.

Pasta & Entrees, Calzones & Rolls, heros, and Garlic Knots share the ticket if the table is not all pizza. We do not list prices here — check the online ordering site.

Walk in, take it home, or deliver it through 10024

Dine-in and takeout run 10AM–10PM daily. Delivery from this kitchen runs 10AM–9PM. Sit at a table on Columbus, pick up a box for an apartment in the 80s, or order if you are staying on Amsterdam or Central Park West.

Order online at order.pizzapetesny.com for 10% off with code ONLINE10 and free delivery, or call (212) 787-3153. Pickup is always 528 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024.

Frequently asked questions