Pizza Pie NYC — Pizza Pete's
Pizza pie NYC is a whole pie from one Upper West Side shop
People searching pizza pie nyc, nyc pizza pie, pie pizza nyc, or pizza pie new york want a whole pie — a box for the table, for pickup, or for delivery — not one slice at the counter. Pizza Pete's bakes that pie at 528 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024, between 85th and 86th Street on the Upper West Side.
We have been the Columbus Avenue pizzeria since 2003. One shop. A citywide pizza-pie search still lands on this kitchen.
A whole-pie order, not a slice, a style page, or a catering tray
This page is the order for a whole pie. Cheese pizza NYC is the plain cheese pie only. New York style pizza NYC is the foldable round style, whether you take a slice or a pie. Pizza in NYC is the general shop page. Best pizza in Manhattan is a borough ranking, not a claim to be the best pizza pie in New York.
Pizza by the slice in Manhattan and pizza slices in NYC are the counter fold. Pizza catering in NYC is party pies for an office, a birthday, or an event. Order pizza online in NYC is how you check out. Same counter at 528 Columbus Avenue. This page stays on the whole pie.
Whole pies on the ordering menu
Round pies on the Pizza board come in a small 13-inch and a large 18-inch. Cheese Pizza is the plain cheese pie, and that item also lets you create your own with the toppings listed there, including pepperoni. White Pizza, Fresh Mozzarella Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Veggie Pizza, and Special Pizza are the other round pies. Special Pizza is mushroom, pepperoni, sausage, pepper, and onion.
Sicilian Cheese Pizza and Sicilian Fresh Mozzarella Pizza are the square pies. Chicago Cheese Pizza and Chicago Fresh Mozzarella Pizza are the pan-style pies. Those four do not use the 13-inch and 18-inch choice. We do not list prices here. Check the online ordering site for the current pie.
Pickup, delivery, or a pie for the table
Dine-in and takeout run 10AM–10PM daily. Delivery from this kitchen runs 10AM–9PM. Online orders to the Upper West Side and surrounding neighborhoods — about 1–2 miles from 528 Columbus Avenue — include free delivery. There is no delivery minimum on online orders. Phone orders may include a delivery fee.
Order a whole pie at order.pizzapetesny.com, or call (212) 787-3153. Pickup is 528 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024. For a scheduled party or office order, start from the pizza catering page. The shop closes at 10PM.
Frequently asked questions
Where do I order a pizza pie in NYC from Pizza Pete's?
Pizza Pete's is at 528 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024, between 85th and 86th Street on the Upper West Side. One shop since 2003. Whole pies — round, Sicilian, and Chicago style — come from that kitchen.
Is a pizza pie the same as a slice, cheese pizza, or catering?
No. This page is a whole pie for pickup, delivery, or a table. Cheese pizza NYC is the plain cheese pie. New York style pizza NYC is the foldable round style. Pizza by the slice is one piece at the counter. Pizza catering NYC is party pies for an event. Order pizza online is checkout. Best pizza in Manhattan is the borough ranking, not the best pizza pie in New York.
What pie sizes and styles can I order?
Round pies on the Pizza board — Cheese, White, Fresh Mozzarella, Buffalo Chicken, Veggie, and Special — come in a small 13-inch and a large 18-inch. Cheese Pizza is plain cheese, or create your own with the toppings listed on the ordering site, including pepperoni. Special Pizza is mushroom, pepperoni, sausage, pepper, and onion. Sicilian Cheese and Sicilian Fresh Mozzarella are square pies. Chicago Cheese and Chicago Fresh Mozzarella are pan-style pies. Those squares and Chicago pies do not offer the 13-inch and 18-inch choice. Prices are on the ordering site.
Order a Whole Pie Online
528 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024 • Open 10AM–10PM daily