Square Pizza in NYC — Pizza Pete's

Square pizza NYC is Sicilian or grandma at this shop

People searching square pizza nyc want a square-cut pie, not a foldable round slice. Pizza Pete's NY bakes two squares: Sicilian and grandma. Both come from one counter at 528 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024, between 85th and 86th Street on the Upper West Side.

We have been that Columbus Avenue pizzeria since 2003. There is no second Pete's. Square pizza here is those two styles — a thick Sicilian square or a thinner grandma square. We do not sell Detroit-style pizza.

Thick Sicilian square or thinner grandma square

Sicilian Pie is the thick-crust square — taller than a grandma slice, with a soft interior and a browned bottom. Sicilian Fresh Mozzarella is that same thick square with fior di latte. Those squares are also served with pepperoni. Grandma Slice is the thinner square: crisp crust, sauce, and mozzarella, cut square without the tall Sicilian rise.

Choose Sicilian when you want the thick square. Choose grandma when you want the thinner square. A whole pie or a single square slice of either style comes off the same board. Round NY-style cheese and pepperoni stay the foldable pies if only part of the table wants a square.

One square search, two named styles

Sicilian is the thick New York square. Grandma is the thin square. Square pepperoni is pepperoni on the Sicilian square, not a third crust. Chicago Cheese and Chicago Fresh Mozzarella sit in their own pan-style category when you want that pie — they are not Detroit-style, and they are not the square-pizza answer on this page.

We do not list prices here. Check the online ordering site for current Sicilian and grandma slice and pie prices.

Order square pizza on the Upper West Side

Eat a square at a table at Pizza Pete's NY, pick it up on Columbus Avenue, or have it delivered through 10024. Dine-in and takeout run 10AM–10PM daily. Delivery from this kitchen runs 10AM–9PM.

Order a Sicilian or grandma square at order.pizzapetesny.com for 10% off with code ONLINE10 and free delivery into 10024, or call (212) 787-3153. Pickup is 528 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024.

Frequently asked questions