Pizza Near Columbus Circle — Pizza Pete's on Columbus Avenue

Same avenue, not a Columbus Circle storefront

Columbus Circle sits at 59th Street, where Columbus Avenue begins. Pizza Pete's is not on the circle and is not a Midtown window — the shop is further up that same avenue on the Upper West Side, at 528 Columbus Avenue between 85th and 86th Street in ZIP 10024.

If you searched pizza near Columbus Circle, treat us as the Columbus Avenue pizzeria you order from for takeout or delivery, not as the nearest door to the circle fountain, Central Park South, or the Deutsche Bank Center.

Takeout and delivery from the Upper West Side shop

People heading to or from Columbus Circle can order NY-style pies, specialty slices, pasta, calzones, and sides for pickup at 528 Columbus or for delivery into the surrounding Upper West Side.

We have been that single shop since 2003. There is no Pete's counter on 59th Street, Eighth Avenue, or the circle itself.

What to order if you are coming up Columbus

A whole pie travels better than an open slice if you are heading back downtown or into an apartment. Cheese, pepperoni, Margherita, white, Sicilian, and the specialty pies are the usual tickets.

Hours are 10AM–10PM daily. Online orders are 10% off with code ONLINE10, and delivery is free. Delivery runs 10AM–9PM.

How to order from Pizza Pete's

Order online at order.pizzapetesny.com or call (212) 787-3153. Pickup is 528 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024 — plan the trip up Columbus Avenue or a delivery window instead of assuming you can stroll over from the circle.

Frequently asked questions