Chicago Style Pizza in NYC — Pizza Pete's
Chicago style pizza from one Columbus Avenue kitchen
Chicago style pizza in NYC at Pizza Pete's is a pan-style pie from the Chicago Pizza category on the live order menu — not a foldable New York slice, and not a second shop dressed up as a dedicated deep-dish parlor. The counter is at 528 Columbus Avenue between 85th and 86th Street on the Upper West Side, ZIP 10024.
If you searched chicago style pizza nyc, that thicker, pan-baked pie comes out of this one UWS kitchen. We have been here since 2003. Dine-in, takeout, and delivery all start on Columbus Avenue.
Chicago Cheese and Chicago Fresh Mozzarella
The Chicago Pizza board lists two named pies: Chicago Cheese and Chicago Fresh Mozzarella. Chicago Cheese is the standard cheese-and-sauce pan pie. Chicago Fresh Mozzarella is the same Chicago-style build with fior di latte, tomato sauce, and basil — a thicker, square-cut pie on live delivery menus.
That category sits next to NY-style rounds and Sicilian squares. Sicilian is the thick New York square; Chicago style is the pan-style option when you want that Midwestern-style pie without leaving the Upper West Side. We do not list prices here — check the online ordering site for current pricing.
Order Chicago style pizza on the Upper West Side
Eat it at a table at Pizza Pete's, pick it up on Columbus Avenue, or have it delivered through 10024. Hours are 10AM–10PM daily; delivery runs 10AM–9PM.
Order online at order.pizzapetesny.com for 10% off with code ONLINE10 and free delivery, or call (212) 787-3153. Pickup is 528 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024.
NY slices still share the ticket
A Chicago-style pie can share the order with a cheese or pepperoni slice, Garlic Knots, or a Sicilian square if the table wants both styles. One kitchen, one Columbus Avenue address — not a Chicago chain window.
Frequently asked questions
Does Pizza Pete's have Chicago style pizza in NYC?
Yes. The live order menu has a Chicago Pizza category with Chicago Cheese and Chicago Fresh Mozzarella. We are at 528 Columbus Avenue between 85th and 86th Street on the Upper West Side, New York, NY 10024.
Is this classic Chicago deep-dish?
The shop lists these as Chicago style / Chicago Pizza pies — a thicker, pan-style pie, not the foldable NY slice. Some live delivery menus describe Chicago Cheese as deep dish and Chicago Fresh Mozzarella as thick and square-cut. Order the named items on the Chicago Pizza board rather than assuming a dedicated deep-dish parlor.
How do I order Chicago style pizza from Pizza Pete's?
Order online at order.pizzapetesny.com (10% off with code ONLINE10 and free delivery), call (212) 787-3153, or come to the counter between 85th and 86th on Columbus Avenue. Hours are 10AM–10PM daily for dine-in, takeout, and delivery.
Order Online — 10% Off + Free Delivery!
528 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024 • Open 10AM–10PM daily