Square Pepperoni Pizza — Pizza Pete's NY Sicilian

Thick square pepperoni pizza in 10024

A square pepperoni pizza at Pizza Pete's NY is a Sicilian pie — thick crust, airy inside, crisp bottom — finished with pepperoni. The shop is at 528 Columbus Avenue between 85th and 86th Street in ZIP 10024. Dine-in, takeout, and delivery all come from that one kitchen.

If you searched square pepperoni pizza, you want the thick Sicilian square, not a foldable New York round slice. We have been that Columbus Avenue pizzeria since 2003.

Sicilian pie with pepperoni — named items on the board

Sicilian Pie is the thick-crust square on the NY-style board. The shop serves those squares with fresh mozzarella, pepperoni, and other toppings. Sicilian Fresh Mozzarella is the specialty square when you want fior di latte in front; add pepperoni if that is the pie you came for.

Pepperoni Pie and Pepperoni Slice are the classic round NY-style versions. Grandma Slice is the thin square. Build Your Own is there if you want to specify the square crust and toppings yourself. We do not list a separate price on this page — check the online ordering site for current pricing.

Dine-in, takeout, or delivery on Columbus

Eat the square at a table at Pizza Pete's NY, pick it up on Columbus Avenue, or have it delivered through the Upper West Side. Hours are 10AM–10PM daily.

Order online for 10% off with code ONLINE10 and free delivery, or call (212) 787-3153. Pickup is 528 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024.

What else goes on the ticket

Garlic Knots from Appetizers & Sides are the usual extra if you are feeding more than one person. A round cheese or Margherita Pie still shares the order if only part of the table wants a square pepperoni.

The same kitchen runs the rest of the specialty board — buffalo chicken, chicken parm, white, and grandma — so a mixed ticket does not mean a second shop.

Frequently asked questions