Pizza on Amsterdam Avenue — Pizza Pete's

Amsterdam Avenue pizza, one block east on Columbus

Amsterdam Avenue in the 80s sits one avenue west of Columbus. Pizza Pete's is not an Amsterdam storefront — the counter is one block east at 528 Columbus Avenue, between 85th and 86th Street. If you searched pizza Amsterdam Avenue or pizza on Amsterdam on the Upper West Side, that one-block walk is the walk to Pete's.

We have been that single UWS shop since 2003. There is no second Pete's on Amsterdam, Broadway, or the 86th Street subway landing.

Slices and pies for Amsterdam in the 80s

Walk east from Amsterdam between 85th and 86th and you hit the slice line: NY-style cheese, pepperoni, Margherita, white, Sicilian, fresh mozzarella, grandma, buffalo chicken, veggie, and build-your-own, plus specialty slices like chicken parm.

Grab a foldable slice at the counter, take a pie back to an Amsterdam Avenue apartment, or sit down in the shop. Hours are 10AM–10PM every day.

Delivery to Amsterdam when you stay on that avenue

If you would rather not cross Columbus with a hot box, we deliver to Amsterdam Avenue and the rest of 10024. The shop is open 10AM–10PM; delivery runs 10AM–9PM.

Order online at order.pizzapetesny.com or call (212) 787-3153. Pickup is still 528 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024.

One shop, one block from Amsterdam

Pizza Pete's NY is the Columbus Avenue pizzeria for Amsterdam in the mid-80s — not a chain window and not a late-night spot past 10. Come for a slice, a whole pie, takeout, or delivery.

Frequently asked questions