Sicilian Pizza in NYC — Pizza Pete's
Sicilian pizza NYC, served from one Upper West Side shop
People searching Sicilian pizza NYC want the thick square, not a citywide chain and not a foldable round slice. Pizza Pete's is one counter at 528 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024, between 85th and 86th Street on the Upper West Side. That kitchen is where the square comes from.
We have been the Columbus Avenue pizzeria since 2003. There is no second Pete's in another borough or another neighborhood. A citywide Sicilian search still lands on this Upper West Side shop.
Thick square crust: a slice or a whole pie
Sicilian at Pizza Pete's is a thick-crust square — taller than a grandma slice, with a soft interior and a browned bottom. Sicilian Pie is the cheese square on the board. Sicilian Fresh Mozzarella is that same thick square with fior di latte. Those squares are also served with pepperoni.
Take a single square slice at the counter, or order a whole Sicilian pie when the table wants the thick cut. It is a different pizza from the round NY-style cheese and pepperoni pies, and a different square from Grandma Slice, which is the thinner square.
Find the square on Columbus Avenue
The shop is on Columbus Avenue between 85th and 86th in ZIP 10024. Dine-in and takeout run 10AM–10PM daily. Delivery from this kitchen runs 10AM–9PM, with free delivery into 10024 on online orders. If you are elsewhere in NYC, the pie is still this Upper West Side counter — come to Columbus Avenue for pickup.
We do not list prices on this page. Check the online ordering site for the current Sicilian slice and pie prices.
Order Sicilian pizza online
Order a slice or a whole pie at order.pizzapetesny.com for 10% off with code ONLINE10 and free delivery into 10024, or call (212) 787-3153. Pickup is 528 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024.
A Sicilian square can share the order with a round NY-style slice, a grandma square, or Garlic Knots. One kitchen on the Upper West Side covers the NYC Sicilian search.
Frequently asked questions
Where do I get Sicilian pizza in NYC from Pizza Pete's?
Pizza Pete's is at 528 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024, between 85th and 86th Street on the Upper West Side. One shop since 2003. Sicilian squares — cheese, fresh mozzarella, or pepperoni — come from that kitchen.
How is Sicilian different from grandma and NY-style pizza?
Sicilian is the thick-crust square, by the slice or as a whole pie. Grandma Slice is the thinner square. NY-style cheese and pepperoni are the round, foldable pies. All three are baked at the same Columbus Avenue counter.
How do I order Sicilian pizza from Pizza Pete's?
Order online at order.pizzapetesny.com (10% off with code ONLINE10 and free delivery into 10024), call (212) 787-3153, or come to the counter. Hours are 10AM–10PM daily for dine-in and takeout; delivery runs 10AM–9PM.
Order Online — 10% Off + Free Delivery!
528 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024 • Open 10AM–10PM daily