Pizza on 86th Street in NYC — Pizza Pete's

Between 85th and 86th on Columbus Avenue

Pizza Pete's sits on Columbus Avenue between 85th and 86th Street, which is why a search for pizza on 86th Street in NYC usually lands here. There is not a second Pete's on the subway landing — this is the shop.

Pizza on 85th Street is the same door. Walk south a few steps from 86th or north a few steps from 85th and you are at 528 Columbus Avenue.

Near the 86th Street subway, still a Columbus shop

If you searched pizza near the 86th Street subway, we are the pizzeria on Columbus in that block, not a station concession. Come off the train, walk to Columbus, and the counter is between the two cross-streets.

The board is NY-style pies and specialty slices: cheese, pepperoni, Margherita, white, Sicilian, fresh mozzarella, grandma, buffalo chicken, veggie, build-your-own, plus chicken parm and the other specialty slices.

Open daily on the 85th–86th block

Hours are 10AM–10PM every day for dine-in, takeout, and delivery. Order online for 10% off with code ONLINE10 and free delivery if you would rather not walk from the station with a pie.

Questions before you come up? Call (212) 787-3153.

One address for 85th and 86th

528 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024 is the only location. Since 2003 this block has been the shop — not a late-night window and not a 24-hour counter.